Constraining the Thermal Contents of X-Ray Cavities in Galaxy Clusters with Sunyaev Zel'dovich Effect Observation

We use Sunyaev Zel'dovich Effect observations at 30 GHz with the Combined Array for Research in Millimeter Astronomy (CARMA) to probe the thermal contents of X-ray cavities in the galaxy cluster MS 0735+741 (MS0735). The hot (3-10 keV), diffuse X-ray emitting atmospheres of galaxy clusters should quickly radiate away its thermal energy via radiative cooling. However, high-resolution X-ray observations from Chandra and XMM have shown that the gas is not cooling to low temperatures at the rates expected, suggesting that the radiative cooling is being balanced by non-gravitational sources of heating. Of primary interest is the energy output from active galactic nuclei (AGN), outbursts from accreting super massive black holes at the center of clusters, which drive radio jets into the atmospheres of clusters and terminate in spectacular radio lobes. High resolution X-ray images have revealed giant cavities produced by the radio lobes displacing the X-ray emitting gas, providing a gauge for the mean mechanical power output of the AGN. These measured powers are enough to offset radiative cooling at the center of relaxed clusters, however, little beyond the energetics of the outbursts is known. The relative balance and efficiency of heating mechanisms for converting the mechanical energy from the AGN into thermal energy in the cluster atmosphere is not well understood, nor are the details of the jets whose contents inflate and support the X-ray cavities. The Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) effect, which is proportional to the line-of-sight pressure of the electrons of the hot gas in galaxy clusters, can shed light on these outstanding issues by directly constraining the thermal contents of the radio-filled X-ray cavities.;In this work, we describe the assembly and commissioning of 1-cm cryogenic receivers for CARMA, which are vital for the high-fidelity SZ observations required for the proposed measurements. CARMA is a 23-element heterogeneous radio interferometer in Cedar Flat, CA. Receivers previously used on the Cosmic Background Imager (CBI) experiment were rebuilt with new low noise amplifiers and updated electronics and installed on the nine 6.1 m telescopes of CARMA, making all 23 CARMA telescopes capable of 1-cm observations. Commissioning observations of the CARMA-23 1-cm instrument took place in February to March of 2013.;The upgraded CARMA-23 instrument is used to observe the SZ effect in the direction of the giant X-ray cavities of MS0735, the most energetic AGN outbursts known (∼ 1062 erg). We model the new CARMA data with a simple analytical model for the SZ signal produced by cavities embedded in an otherwise relaxed cluster, and supplement the model with X-ray and radio observations of MS0735 from Chandra and VLA. We find a sharp contrast in the SZ signal highly coincident with the X-ray identified cavities, suggesting a lack of SZ contributing material in the cavities and representing the first ever detection of these phenomena with the SZ effect. Our model strongly disfavors the cavities containing thermal gas of < 150 keV. If the pressure support in the bubbles is thermal, it is likely several hundreds to thousands of keV and very diffuse (<10-4 cm-3 ). Or alternatively, our findings are consistent with bubbles supported non-thermally by relativistic particles or magnetic fields.