Font Size: a A A

Inference To The Best Explanation And Induction

Posted on:2014-10-15Degree:MasterType:Thesis
Country:ChinaCandidate:F J LinFull Text:PDF
GTID:2255330398482702Subject:Logic
Abstract/Summary:PDF Full Text Request
Research has shown that,Inference to the best explanation (namely IBE) is a very important type of reasoning.This inference which derived from notation named abduction that is first present by C.S.Peircewas firstly mentioned and explained by G.Harmon,its main idea is:explanatory consideration can be director of inference.Inference to the best explanation already has become a very important theme after investigating by philosophers,such as P.R.Thagard,P.Lipton,etc. P.Lipton claimed that IBE describe the mechnism in the black box of induction very well,moreover,it can be used to justify some particular inductive principles.However, many philosophers are anxious for IBE,first of all,how to find out the best explantion;secondly,how loveness become the director of likeness;thirdly,whether IBE really has some virtues it claimed;lastly,how much IBE is good for justification of induction.All these questions are crucial for IBE and induction.Our article is mostly established in related investigation of P.Lipton who did study very well on IBE, we analyze different objection and modification,so as to modify illustration about IBE written by P.Lipton reasonably and establish its significant status on descrption of induction and its great significance on justifiction of induction.In order to evolve the article orderly,I divide the article into four parts:The first part mainly presents origin of IBE and its early development.In the second part,we will witness mostly features of IBE through related expliction of P.Lipton.well,this chapter we set forth model of explanation which P.Lipton’s IBE was based on,then we introduce two important distinction presented by P.Lipton for indicating substance of IBE;at last,I indicate how we can find out best explantion and do IBE according to thinking of P.Lipton.The third part is emphasis of this article,yeah, we will confront the great significance of P.Lipton’s IBE for induction.From description aspect we will make certain,it is a better description of induction;from justifiction aspect we will know,it is meaningful for some some inductive princeples. The four part is most import.From the P.Lipton’s IBE came out,it faced with objections and doubts,so how to regard these opinions is the theme of this part.we will reply to those objections and doubts,and indicate that if we develop and explicate P.Lipton’IBE,then it has no problem to treat IBE as a better description of induction.In additional,we also will show,IBE’ benefits for justification of induction are much more than P.Lipton had thought,we can exploit more treasure from it.Through discussion in the four parts we will finally understand that IBE has had a quite long history,it actually is inference to the loveliest potential explanation,and it is IBE that lighten the road we describe and justify induction.
Keywords/Search Tags:Inference to the best explanation, causal model, loveness, likeness, Induction
PDF Full Text Request
Related items