Against instrumentalism | | Posted on:2011-07-02 | Degree:M.A | Type:Thesis | | University:University of Guelph (Canada) | Candidate:Hogg, Jeremy | Full Text:PDF | | GTID:2445390002967307 | Subject:Philosophy | | Abstract/Summary: | PDF Full Text Request | | Instrumenalism says: practical rationality is only about taking the appropriate means to your ends and that practical reasoning is only a matter of deliberating about the means to your ends. I say: (a) instrumentalism cannot account for the rationality of choosing a greater good (for oneself) over a smaller but more local (or present) good, (b) instrumentalist accounts of ends in terms of pleasure and desire- satisfaction (the default views) are problematic, and (c) cost-benefit analysis suggests that for both the purpose of describing deliberative behavior and evaluating it, it is more practical to treat ends as heterogeneous -- whereas instrumentalists traditionally commit to treating ends as homogeneous. | | Keywords/Search Tags: | Ends, Practical | PDF Full Text Request | Related items |
| |
|