Initiation and growth of multiple-site damage in the riveted lap joint of a curved stiffened fuselage panel: An experimental and analytical study

As part of the structural integrity research of the National Aging Aircraft Research Program, a comprehensive study on multiple-site damage (MSD) initiation and growth in a pristine lap-joint fuselage panel has been conducted. The curved stiffened fuselage panel was tested at the Full-Scale Aircraft Structural Test Evaluation and Research (FASTER) facility located at the Federal Aviation Administration William J. Hughes Technical Center. A strain survey test was conducted to verify proper load application. The panel was then subjected to a fatigue test with constant-amplitude cyclic loading. The applied loading spectrum included underload marker cycles so that crack growth history could be reconstructed from post-test fractographic examinations. Crack formation and growth were monitored via nondestructive and high-magnification visual inspections.; Strain gage measurements recorded during the strain survey tests indicated that the inner surface of the skin along the upper rivet row of the lap joint experienced high tensile stresses due to local bending. During the fatigue loading, cracks were detected by eddy-current inspections at multiple rivet holes along the upper rivet row. Through-thickness cracks were detected visually after about 80% of the fatigue life. Once MSD cracks from two adjacent rivet holes linked up, there was a quick deterioration in the structural integrity of the lap joint. The linkup resulted in a 2.87" (72.9-mm) lead fatigue crack that rapidly propagated across 12 rivet holes and crossed over into the next skin bay, at which stage the fatigue test was terminated. A post-fatigue residual strength test was then conducted by loading the panel quasi-statically up to final failure. The panel failed catastrophically when the crack extended instantaneously across three additional bays.; Post-test fractographic examinations of the fracture surfaces in the lap joint of the fuselage panel were conducted to characterize subsurface crack initiation and growth. Results showed evidence of fretting damage and crack initiation at multiple locations near the rivet holes along the faying surface of the skin. The subsurface cracks grew significantly along the faying surface before reaching the outer surface of the skin, forming elliptical crack fronts.; A finite element model (FE) of the panel was constructed and geometrically-nonlinear analyses conducted to determine strain distribution under the applied loads. The FE model was validated by comparing the analysis results with the strain gage measurements recorded during the strain survey test. The validated FE model was then used to determine stress-intensity factors at the crack tips. Stress-intensity factor results indicated that crack growth in the lap joint was under mixed-mode; however, the opening-mode stress intensity factor was dominant. The stress-intensity factors computed from the FE analysis were used to conduct cycle-by-cycle integration of fatigue crack growth. In the cycle-by-cycle integration, the NASGRO crack growth model was used with its parameters selected to account for the effects of plasticity-induced crack closure and the test environment on crack growth rate. Fatigue crack growth predictions from cycle-by-cycle computation were in good agreement with the experimental measured crack growth data.; The results of the study provide key insights into the natural development and growth of MSD cracks in the pristine lap joint. The data provided by the study represent a valuable source for the evaluation and validation of analytical methodologies used for predicting MSD crack initiation and growth.