Font Size: a A A

Economic Analysis of Amendments to the Indian Constitution

Posted on:2014-11-16Degree:Ph.DType:Dissertation
University:George Mason UniversityCandidate:Rajagopalan, ShrutiFull Text:PDF
GTID:1456390008461435Subject:Economics
Abstract/Summary:
The Indian Parliament has amended the Indian Constitution ninety-seven times since its ratification in 1950. Fundamental Rights in India were amended frequently, specifically the right to private property, which was deleted in 1978 through the Forty-Fourth Amendment. These amendments gradually removed the constitutional constraints placed by the founding fathers on democratic decision-making.;In this dissertation, I analyze the role of the ideology and interests of political entrepreneurs in forming and amending constitutional rules in postcolonial India. I also examine the robustness of the amendment process and its vulnerability to political and ideological capture by interest groups in the post-constitutional setting in India.;In the first essay, I argue that frequent constitutional amendments are a consequence of the incompatibility between socialism and constitutionalism in India. I provide evidence from constitutional amendments and Supreme Court cases to show that the Constitution was amended to execute the objectives and targets of the Five-Year Plans.;In the second essay, I examine the role of ideology and interests of the Constituent Assembly, consequently creating a weak procedure for amending property rights. I find that the socialist ideology of the founding fathers, and their fear of markets and private predation, reduced the voting requirements for amending property rights.;In the third essay, I examine the consequent political opportunism and constitutional rent seeking due to a weak amendment procedure; and explain the creation, expansion and recent dormancy of the Ninth Schedule of the Constitution. Using the 282 laws in the Ninth Schedule, I show that a combination of weak procedural rules and strong substantive rights, led to rent seeking at a constitutional level, despite the institution of independent judicial review.
Keywords/Search Tags:Constitution, India, Rights, Amendments
Related items