The Three-Dimensional Mass Measurement Of Subsolid Pulmonary Nodules On Chest CT: Intra And Inter-Observer Variability

Objective Subsolid pulmonary nodules tend to exhibit considerably slower growth rates than solid lesions, nevertheless, higher malignancy probability. The diagnosis of indeterminate nodules largely depends on the growth evaluation during follow-up. The growth can manifested as an increase in size or the appearance and/or subsequent increase of solid components. The mass reflect the product of volume and density and can be more sensitive in growth evaluation. However, the repeatability needs a further validation. The purpose of this study is to assess the intra and inter-observer variability of mass measurement for subsolid nodules.Materials and Methods 80 subsolid nodules in 44 patients were retrospectively enrolled. Both the volume and mass were measured by two radiologists using blind method independently. Intra-observer and inter-observer variability were analyzed and compared by Bland-Altman method、intra-class correlation test and Wilcoxon test.Results Software achieved satisfied segmentation for 92.5% nodules. Of them, 35% underwent manual modification。The 95% limits of agreement for intra-observer variability were-11.5% ~ 10.4% for mass and-8.4% ~ 8.8% for volume. The 95% limits of agreement for inter-observer variability were-17.4% ~ 19.3% for mass and-17.9% ~ 19.4% for volume.The intra-class correlation foefficients between volume and mass measument was 0.95 and 0.93(both P<0.001) and no significant differences(P=0.78、0.09) was found for intra- and inter- observer variability. Manual modification of the segmentation caused the worse mass measurement repeatability in spite of the reader satisfaction.Conclusion The repeatability of mass measurement has no significant difference with that of volume measurement and may act as a reliable method in the follow-up of subsolid nodules.