The Compare Of Hongxue Research Between Hu Shi And Yupingbo

"A Dream of Red Mansions " writes approximately at the Qing Dynasty Qianlong middle period, is honored as our country"the feudalism end world encyclopedia", is our country classical novel work crest. The Hong studies study well-established, the school is numerous. And take Hu Shi, Yu Pingbo as representative's research faction is an important faction, they attacks probes into a concealed or secret matter the faction guesses a riddle makes false analogies or strained interpretations-like the method and the viewpoint, proposed the science research technique, has delimited the research scope, established has been different with the former research model, affected profoundly in the Hong studies history.The new Hongxue' establishment has the vital academic significance. This article is for the purpose of through to researching sends two big leader Hu Shi and Yu Pingbo's research technique and the achievement is more comprehensive and the detailed comparison, on the one hand the exploration research sends the Hong studies research the development process; On the other hand, summarizes inherits, profits from, the resonsideration, the surmounting importance unceasingly in the scholarly research. This regarding Hongxue research's health advancement, further develops has certain significance without doubtThis article main body comparison is divided five parts. one is Hu Shi and the Yu Pingbo Hongxue research technique comparison. Hu Shi and Yu Pingbo's research technique with belongs to the textual criticism scope, the general orientation is the same. But, two person of concrete methods have the difference, therefore studies has the stress respectively. Hu Shi obtains by the historical material to carry on the research, belongs to the science rigorous history textual criticism category. In Yu Pingbo's research are more from the text begins to seek proves, has the literary criticism, the literature connoisseurship nature. Its research technique appears the research to send with the novel criticism to send the confluence the trend. SecondHu Shi and Yu Pingbo about " A Dream of Red Mansions " and family background research quite. Hu Shi in the massive historical data's foundation, has established Cao Xueqin to " A Dream of Red Mansions " the copyright, and has researched Cao Xueqin's family background, this is he to a Hong studies history big contribution. Yu Pingbo mainly follows Hu Shi's viewpoint, simultaneously, he unifies the work itself,"in proves"from the text obtains, has further irrevocably proven Hu Shi's viewpoint. Two person of mutual influences, cause Cao Xueqin and the family background research receive the attention day by day, and becomes the later generation a famous doctrine.Third, Hu Shi and Yu Pingbo about"from narrates the biography"the viewpoint similarities and differences. Hu Shi proposed for the first time"from narrates the biography"the viewpoint, and the life initiative, insisted from narrated. Yu Pingbo regarding from manner following which from the very beginning narrated to afterward unceasingly reconsidered revises, until abandoned completely finally, has manifested the science rigorous academic manner as well as in a Hong studies research big surmounting.Forth are Hu Shi and Yu Pingbo about " A Dream of Red Mansions " the edition comparison. Hu Shi established "Hong Lou Meng" the edition study, particularly is very big to armor eleventh of the twelve Earthly Branches this discovery and the introduction contribution. Although Hu Shi has some viewpoints in the edition research not to be correct, some conclusions qualitative are not very strict, but generally speaking merits outweigh demerits. Yu Pingbo's edition research involved Hu Shi not once penetrated has researched the book, has developed "Hong Lou Meng" the edition research scope, this was Yu Pingbo to Hu Shi's surmounting, was also to " A Dream of Red Mansions " the edition research contribution.Fifth, Hu Shi and Yu Pingbo to latter 40 continue the book the comparison. Hu Shi to latter 40 continued the book to make the preliminary research, determined that " A Dream of Red Mansions " first 80 was not one person does with the latter 40 chapters, and through the research determined that Gao E was the author who continued the book. Yu Pingbo to continued the book in Hu Shi's foundation to conduct the thorough research.