A Re-examination Of The Authenticity Of The Publication Of Jin Lvxiang's "Notes On Shangshu"

Jin Luxiang is a famous scholar in the development history of Shangshu in the communication period of Song and Yuan Dynasties.His study of Shangshu runs through his whole life and forms a unique academic system of annotation,discussion,application and expression.Jin Luxiang was born intelligent,his sagacity was appeared when he is young.On the basis of inheriting the family studies,he followed Wang Bai and He Ji in his early years,and completed the twelve volumes of Shangshu Annotation(this is the “annotation”)in the form of "Every chapter explains,every sentence answers",which laid the foundation for his lifelong study of Shangshu.It is on the basis of Shujing Zhu that Jin Luxiang put forward a series of the discussions with important academic value in the history of Shangshu(this is " discussion ")and eighteen volumes of historical masterpiece Before History As A Mirror(this is " application ").Jin Luxiang integrated his annotation of Shangshu,discussion of Shangshu and application of Shangshu into one pot through his original " express style",which was included in Shangshu Expression completed in his later years(this is "Expression").There are two kinds of Shangshu Annotation that can be printed and signed by Jin Luxiang in his early years,that is,Bi Linlang Hall series(hereinafter referred to as Bi Lin)twelve volumes of Jin's Shangshu Annotation and Shi Wanjuanlou series(hereinafter referred to as Wanjuanlou)twelve volumes of Shujing Zhu,These two book exists controversy about true and false.Xu Yulong and Cai Genxiang of Taiwan believe that the twelve volumes of Bilin Jin's Shangshu Annotation is the forgery of Chen Shikai's Shucaizhuan Pangtong.Cai Genxiang's textual research shows that Wanjuanlou twelve volumes of Shujing Zhu,which are collected from Before History As A Mirror by futurities is forgery.Professor Wang Xiaohong of Sichuan University considered that Wanjuanlou's Shujing Zhu was not a forgery by her textual research.Based on the systematic arrangement of the twelve volumes of Bilin Jin's Shangshu Annotation,through the analysis of the relevant historical documents,the detailed examination of the book's signature and text,and combined with the relevant research results of Xu Yulong and Cai Genxiang,it can be basically determined that the twelve volumes of Bilin Jin's Shang shu Annotation is forgery.On the basis of systematically sorting out the twelve volumes of Wanjuanlou's Shujng Zhu,by analyzing the relevant historical documents and combining with the existing relevant research results of Cheng Yuanmin and Wang Xiaohong,this paper made a textual research on Cai Genxiang's "falsification" motivation one by one,and can basically judge that the twelve volumes of Wanjuanlou's Shujing Zhu is true.It should be a book written by Jin Luxiang in his early years.The twelve volumes of Wanjuanlou's Shujing Zhu not only laid the foundation for the system of Shangshu's discussion,application and expression,but also embodied many innovations in methodology and ideology,which deeply influenced the development of Shang shu's research in Yuan,Ming,Qing and modern times.This book take annotation about Shang shu in the form of "Every chapter explains,every sentence answers",which set a precedent of Song dynasty people's turn from argumentation to textual research.Jin Luxiang is "an important link in the transition from Song studies to Qing studies" and "academic achievements in the three hundred years of the Qing Dynasty were born out of him."...