Analysis And Refutation Of "Tucker-Wood Thesis"

This article focuses on a classic thesis in the western theoretical world,The Tucker-Wood Thesis,and uses it as a starting point to derive some reflections on Marx's view of justice.In the early 1970 s,John Rawls published his most famous masterpiece,"The Theory of Justice," and the enthusiastic discussion of the topic of justice in Western theoretical circles followed.As a projection of this boom in the field of Marxist theory,the Tucker-Wood Thesis once caused an uproar in the field of theory,because of what it called the "defense" impression of the core view of justice.For Tucker-Wood Thesis,according to many scholars of classical texts of Marx tried to refute them,thereby producing a series of discussions,and therefore gradually sketched out a preliminary lines Marx's view of justice.And the 21 st century,Chinese theorists have begun to show concern about this issue and into a lot of thought and discussion.From their results,on the one hand,it greatly increases the thickness and details of Marx's theory of justice,and on the other hand,some of the core problems still waiting for scholars to reach a consensus.Therefore we can say,a system of Marx and the whole concept of justice,both near and far away from us.At the same time,the pluralistic and rapid development of modern society in economic,political,cultural and other fields inevitably brings various social problems and contradictions.A large part of the reason is the "morality" caused by "lack of justice" Anomie." No matter from the perspective of theory or practice,a Marx concept of justice,which has both theoretical convincing power and practical execution power,urgently calls for people to explore and pursue.For the purpose of exploring Marx's view of justice,this article takes the Tucker-Wood Thesis as an entry point,and attempts to further analyze the focus and core of this controversy by restoring and combing the controversy elicited from this thesis,and hopes that eventually Can get relevant thinking about Marx's theory of justice.Based on this clue,this article will be divided into four parts.The first part is an introduction.In this part,the author introduces the theoretical background of the topic,the status of domestic and foreign research,research methods and its theoretical significance.The second part is based on the Tucker-Wood Thesis.The core content of this article is unfolded;in the third part,the theorists' huge controversy over the Tucker-Wood Thesis is shown from the perspectives of Husami,Cohen and Geras;In the past,try to analyze a mild reason for the controversy of the Tucker-Wood Thesis,so as to further resolve the challenges of the Tucker-Wood Thesis.